Episode 89: "Faith is not soft" with Blake Yager, Team Chaplain

March 6, 2025

Watch on Youtube Listen on Apple Podcasts

In this profound episode of The Mental Mettle Podcast, host Coach Matt Thomann sits down with Blake Yager—former collegiate athlete, team chaplain, and advocate for faith-driven resilience—to explore how spiritual fortitude and mental toughness intersect in the lives of athletes.

From Athlete to Chaplain: Blake’s Journey

Blake Yager’s story begins on the football field, where he battled not just opponents but personal struggles that threatened to derail his career. After facing setbacks in college athletics, he discovered that faith was far from a “soft” crutch—it became the bedrock of his mental resilience. Now serving as a team chaplain, Blake bridges the gap between spiritual growth and athletic excellence, offering a unique perspective on how faith fuels perseverance.

Faith as a Foundation for Mental Toughness

Blake challenges the misconception that faith weakens competitive edge:

“Faith isn’t about weakness; it’s the foundation of true mental strength. It’s about standing firm when your body wants to quit and your mind tells you to walk away.”

Key insights from the discussion include:

Embracing struggle as refinement: How faith transforms adversity into purpose.
The role of prayer in pressure moments: Using spiritual practices to stay grounded during high-stakes competition.
Building a “team-first” mentality: Why selflessness rooted in faith strengthens camaraderie and performance.

Redefining Identity Beyond the Field

A central theme of the episode is the danger of tying self-worth to athletic performance. Blake shares his own journey of overcoming identity crises after injuries and unmet expectations:

“When your jersey is stripped away, who are you? Faith taught me that my value isn’t in touchdowns or trophies—it’s in something unshakable.”

Practical advice for athletes and coaches:

Daily grounding rituals: Start practices with reflection or meditation to align purpose.
Vulnerability as strength: Creating safe spaces for athletes to discuss fears and doubts.
Mentorship beyond skills: Coaching the whole person, not just the player.

Key Takeaways for Listeners

Faith and grit are complementary: Spiritual resilience fuels physical and mental endurance.
Serve to lead: Blake’s chaplaincy work highlights how uplifting others strengthens team culture.
Identity anchors: Athletes thrive when rooted in purpose beyond wins and losses.

Tune In and Transform Your Mindset

Whether you’re an athlete navigating burnout, a coach seeking to inspire, or someone searching for deeper resilience, this episode offers actionable wisdom. Blake’s story proves that faith isn’t a retreat from challenges—it’s a rallying cry to face them with courage.Listen now to discover how to forge unshakable mental mettle through faith, and subscribe to The Mental Mettle Podcast for more transformative conversations. Ready to deepen your resilience? Connect with Coach Matt Thomann at coachthomann@gmail.com or visit www.mentalmettlelifecoaching.com to start your journey.

Are you ready to forge your mettle?

More From Mental Mettle

Episode 154: Secrets Behind the Third Skill Set: Mental Performance

Most athletes train hard in two areas: sport skills and strength. But there’s a third skill set that often gets ignored, and it may be the one that matters most when pressure hits. In Episode 154 of The Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Matt Thomann breaks down the real difference-maker in sports performance: mental performance.

Ember to Inferno: Building Mentally Tough Athletes Through Coach Development

Coaches spend countless hours perfecting physical training and game strategies, but mental toughness—the ability to thrive under pressure, regulate emotions, and respond to adversity—often gets overlooked. That's where Ember to Inferno comes in.

Episode 151: Before the Crisis – How Coach Chad Cluver’s Habits Shape Team Adversity Response

In Episode 151 of the Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Chad Cluver shares how the habits, standards, and culture he builds every day prepare his teams to handle pressure when it shows up.

Episode 149: Never Done Learning with HOF Coach Pat Ryan

Coach Pat Ryan has spent a lifetime building football the right way: with consistency, toughness, relationships, and a commitment to never stop learning. In this episode of The Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Matt Thomann sits down with the longtime Metamora High School head coach and current Director of High School Relations for Illinois Football to talk about what really sustains success in coaching.

Toxic Motivators: How Fear, Lust, Anger, and Pride Quietly Shape Performance

In Episode 147 of the Mental Metal Podcast, Coach Matt Toman and Dr. Dave Jones unpack a powerful idea that applies to athletes, coaches, parents, and leaders alike: the biggest performance problems are often not physical, but motivational.

Episode 147: Fear vs. Faith with Dr. Dave Jones: Beating Toxic Motivators with True Mental Toughness

Episode 147 of The Mental Mettle Podcast features former pro hockey player, Air Force veteran, and sport and performance psychologist Dr. Dave Jones for a powerful conversation about fear, faith, and true mental toughness. What began as a brutal slap shot to the face eventually rerouted Dave’s life toward the Air Force, pro hockey in Germany, faith, and the work he now does helping high performers build a healthier mindset.

View all