What does it really take to develop a mentally tough athlete?

For much of his coaching career, Jeremy Adolphson thought the answer was more conditioning: make athletes tired, make practice uncomfortable, and trust that the experience would toughen them up. After 26 years as a head football coach, his perspective has changed. Today, he believes athletes perform best when they have practiced the skills they need, understand their roles, and know how to respond when things go wrong.

In Episode 174 of The Mental Mettle Podcast, I sit down with Jeremy to talk about that shift—and what it means for the way we coach.

Jeremy is the athletic director, a math and PE teacher, and the head football coach at Monmouth-Roseville High School in Monmouth, Illinois. Now in his 28th year in education and 16th year leading the Titans, he brings more than 100 career wins and multiple playoff runs to the conversation. But this episode is less about his record than about what he has learned while helping young people get ready to play.

Preparation Builds Confidence

Conditioning has a place in athletics. But being exhausted is not the same as knowing what to do under pressure.

Jeremy and I discuss how confidence grows when athletes develop their skills, practice situations that resemble the game, and receive clear answers when they make mistakes. Instead of simply telling a player what went wrong, a coach can give them a solution to try on the next rep. The goal is to prepare athletes to make decisions—not leave them afraid of making the wrong one.Ep.-168-It-s-Supposed-to-Be-Hard.-How-to-Use-Adversity-in-Athletics-to-Build-Mental-Toughness.txt

That preparation also means recognizing what each athlete does well. Jeremy shares the story of “The Jake,” a role built around a player’s strengths, as an example of how coaches can help athletes contribute and play with confidence.

Practice the Hard Moments

Games will bring mistakes, pressure, and adversity. Athletes should not encounter those moments for the first time when the outcome is on the line.

In this episode, we talk about making practice look more like competition, giving athletes room to fail and adjust, and building a culture where questions are welcome. Coaches have a part in that culture, too: they must model the composure, willingness to learn, and response to setbacks that they ask of their players.

We discuss:

  • Why conditioning and mental toughness are not the same thing.
  • How skill, preparation, and role clarity build confidence.
  • Why practice should prepare athletes for game-like decisions.
  • How to correct mistakes by giving athletes solutions.
  • Why failure and adversity belong in practice.
  • How coaches can model the mental toughness they want to develop.
  • Why athletes need to feel comfortable asking questions.

The takeaway is not that coaches should stop challenging athletes. It is that a challenge works best when athletes have been taught how to meet it.

Prepare them. Build their confidence. Then let them play.

Connect with Jeremy on X: @MonRoseFB. Learn more about Mental Mettle Coaching, and share this episode with a coach who could use the conversation.

Forge Your Mettle.

Are you ready to forge your mettle?

More From Mental Mettle

Episode 179: Sports Are a Platform, Not a Purpose with Tanner Field of B-Third Athletics
In Episode 179 of The Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Matt Thomann sits down with Tanner Field, founder of B3rd Athletics, for a conversation about faith, competition, mental toughness, and the responsibility coaches have to develop the whole person.
The Mental Skills Athletes Need Most: Turning “Be Tougher” Into a Trainable System
Too often, coaches and parents use “be tougher” as a shortcut for an entire mental-performance plan. The phrase may communicate urgency, but it rarely tells an athlete what to do next. A more useful approach is to define the mental skill, teach it, practice it in a low-pressure setting, and reinforce it during competition.
Episode 178: Authenticity, Adaptability, and Faith | Matt Bollant on Coaching
In Episode 178 of The Mental Mettle Podcast, I sit down with veteran college basketball coach Matt Bollant, now the head women’s basketball coach at Southwest Baptist University, for a conversation about authentic leadership, faith, and developing young people. His experiences offer an important reminder: knowing yourself matters, but so does having the humility to change your approach.
Episode 177: Coaching 4 Character | Coach Will Rey on 50 Years of Building Better People
In Episode 177 of The Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Thomann sits down with Coach Will Rey, head varsity basketball coach at Northridge Prep School, for a conversation about building better people through athletics. Entering his 50th year of coaching, with experience at both the college and high school levels, Coach Rey brings a perspective shaped by decades of teaching, competing, and growing alongside his players.
Episode 176: Toughness Takes Practice | Lexi Demott, Galesburg Girls Basketball Head Coach
In Episode 176 of The Mental Mettle Podcast, I sit down with Lexi Demott, Head Girls Basketball Coach at Galesburg High School, to explore that question. Her approach goes beyond telling players to “be tougher.” She defines what toughness looks like, gives athletes tools to practice it, and brings those lessons into everyday conversations, drills, and competition.
National Coaches Day: How Coaches Support Athlete Mental Health
Discover how coaches can support athlete mental health, build resilience, and strengthen team culture with Mental Mettle’s coach development services.