Episode 137: Making football the best part of a kid's day with State Champion Coach Garrett Mueller

January 12, 2026

Watch on Youtube Listen on Apple Podcasts

Winning is great, but making football the best part of a kid’s day might be an even bigger victory.

In Episode 137 of The Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Matt Thomann sits down with State Champion Coach Garrett Mueller, head football coach at Stewartville High School in Minnesota, to explore how a major shift in philosophy reshaped his program and his players’ experience of the game. Over 18 years of coaching (15 at Stewartville, 8 as head coach), Mueller has led his team to a 70–14 record, two state championships, and a 30-game win streak—while intentionally moving away from the traditional grind model of football.

From grind culture to joyful, sprint-based football

Mueller shares why he stepped back from old-school, punishment-heavy conditioning and adopted Feed the Cats and sprint-based football, a change that impacted both performance and player wellbeing. By shortening practices, emphasizing high-intensity work, and treating football as the best part of a kid’s day instead of a daily beatdown, his staff saw players run faster, recover better, and actually look forward to practice. This episode highlights how joy, mental health, and recovery can coexist with a championship standard on the field.

Culture, family, and avoiding burnout

The conversation also dives into coaching alongside his Hall of Fame father, now on staff with him, and what it means to coach his own sons in a healthy way. Mueller explains why Stewartville intentionally avoids pushing early tackle football, how they think about youth burnout, and what he does when success dips to re-center on core principles instead of panicking. A key tool he shares is the “Hunt the Good Stuff” mindset, training players to deliberately look for positives and build resilient confidence day after day.

If you are a coach, parent, or athlete who believes there has to be a better way than endless conditioning, punishments, and grind culture, Episode 137 will give you a clear, proven alternative for building both performance and mental strength. Subscribe to The Mental Mettle Podcast and start forging your 100% Mettle today, and to learn more or schedule a free coaching session with Coach Thomann, visit mentalmettlelifecoaching.com or email coachthomann@gmail.com.

Are you ready to forge your mettle?

More From Mental Mettle

Episode 154: Secrets Behind the Third Skill Set: Mental Performance

Most athletes train hard in two areas: sport skills and strength. But there’s a third skill set that often gets ignored, and it may be the one that matters most when pressure hits. In Episode 154 of The Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Matt Thomann breaks down the real difference-maker in sports performance: mental performance.

Ember to Inferno: Building Mentally Tough Athletes Through Coach Development

Coaches spend countless hours perfecting physical training and game strategies, but mental toughness—the ability to thrive under pressure, regulate emotions, and respond to adversity—often gets overlooked. That's where Ember to Inferno comes in.

Episode 151: Before the Crisis – How Coach Chad Cluver’s Habits Shape Team Adversity Response

In Episode 151 of the Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Chad Cluver shares how the habits, standards, and culture he builds every day prepare his teams to handle pressure when it shows up.

Episode 149: Never Done Learning with HOF Coach Pat Ryan

Coach Pat Ryan has spent a lifetime building football the right way: with consistency, toughness, relationships, and a commitment to never stop learning. In this episode of The Mental Mettle Podcast, Coach Matt Thomann sits down with the longtime Metamora High School head coach and current Director of High School Relations for Illinois Football to talk about what really sustains success in coaching.

Toxic Motivators: How Fear, Lust, Anger, and Pride Quietly Shape Performance

In Episode 147 of the Mental Metal Podcast, Coach Matt Toman and Dr. Dave Jones unpack a powerful idea that applies to athletes, coaches, parents, and leaders alike: the biggest performance problems are often not physical, but motivational.

Episode 147: Fear vs. Faith with Dr. Dave Jones: Beating Toxic Motivators with True Mental Toughness

Episode 147 of The Mental Mettle Podcast features former pro hockey player, Air Force veteran, and sport and performance psychologist Dr. Dave Jones for a powerful conversation about fear, faith, and true mental toughness. What began as a brutal slap shot to the face eventually rerouted Dave’s life toward the Air Force, pro hockey in Germany, faith, and the work he now does helping high performers build a healthier mindset.

View all